Shopify is a good fit when the business wants a proven store system, easy product management and access to a large app and fulfillment ecosystem.
A custom online store can make more sense when products, checkout, payments, shipping or business rules need to work in a very specific way.
There is also a middle option: build the main website custom and let Shopify power the store. The right choice depends on how the business sells and manages products, not on loyalty to one platform.

